2011年10月5日 星期三

Annotation1- Is this occasion an euthanasia or a threat to death?

 Death penalty is a controversial issue for us because we regard human right as an important thing. Criminals are given many rights like reading newspapers, proper right of law. On the issue of animal euthanasia, many people will think that euthanasia is a painless way of death. However, if we see the cruel truth in the shelter or know how large amount of the stray dogs will die in one day, can we still keep quiet about this issue? First, the euthanasia technologists use a stick with fixer to drop the dog out. As we can see, the scene is so rough and brutal. The dog is not dead yet, it still has feelings like pain and fear. Nevertheless, it seems no one in this shelter has cared about this. Second, they needle to put the medicine into its heart, not just put it to death straightly, but sting it over and over again and make it longer dieing pain. Because the constant moving of the dog, the needle can not sting straightly to heart, but usually to pleural. The efficient of medicine will become slower and cause longer and struggling pain. This kind of occasions happen more often than stinging needles straight to their heart and make them die peacefully. Third, the dogs are just piled up on the wet and dirty floor to be thrown to burn. This scene shows that they completely do not have their own dignity at all.
  These three things shocked me most. The first shocking scene makes think the question like: why does the euthanasia technologist have to use that kind of tool to take the dog out? Can’t we use some ways that are tenderer and make them less painful? For example, use a rope for owners to walk their dogs. They can be taken out in peaceful atmosphere, without pain and fear during the process of being taken out to die. My thoughts to the second scene are connected to the thoughts of the first scene. If the dogs can be treated tenderly, then the procedure of taking them out will be simpler. Therefore, needling will be more efficient. Dogs can go through this process less painful, and people who need to do these things as work can finish it quicker and the burden of hearts can be less than before. The third scene is the problem of surroundings. If the place which used to kill the dogs is dirty, then in the same thoughts, the living surroundings are not comfortable for sure. Dogs are caught and cared by people; however no matter whether they are living or dead, their existence do not have dignity at all. Their lives will only be more valuable once people start to focus on their dignity. Is the euthanasia really reasonable, do people really have right to end other animal’s lives? If people are really going to make them die, the dignity should be provided and not be ignored.  

3 則留言:

  1. I was shocked after watching the video. To be honest, I was feel that euthanasia is a reasonable way to reduce the problem. However, this video proves that I was wrong. The process is too brutal, and it really hurt the dogs a lot.
    About your article, you mention a lot of the truth of euthanasia, but I can not recognize that which side do you stand for. Are you agree with the euthanasia of dog, or you are just focusing on the treatment of stray dogs?

    回覆刪除
  2. Because you use one video as a reference, you can put on the website of this video to make readers know where you got the information. I notice that you just combine your feeling and thoughts with the summarization of the video. I think it will be better if you depart them because the way you do might confuse the readers. You can make a brief summarization of the video first, and then state your standpoint. It can be more clear and efficient than combining your ideas and the summarization together.

    回覆刪除
  3. I have some humble feedback after watching this video.

    The uneasiness or sorrow felt by you after you learn the truth of euthanasia is a very important part of humanity that is known as compassion. Compassion literally means the sympathetic pity and concern for the suffering or misfortune of others. A great portion of people, especially in the modernized society, has ceased to possess this crucial element of humanity since we are separated from the environment and other human being. Ironically, Our lives are ever more interdependent on the others when advancement of technology and the wheels of commerce bring us closer yet we are ever more separated from the others when we are connected by the increasingly immense network of the internet and cellphone.

    When we could still feel sorry for the misery of the stray animals, we have to think of other animals that are being consumed, or more close to the truth, eaten. Here I give my humble message that I think everyone should re-think this question. Why do we feel bad for the stray dogs while we can eat some other animals? If we despise the dog-eating people on main land China, what is so different eating a pig or cow?

    Thank you for reading till the end.



    Jim

    回覆刪除